Gibson Electric Services logo
Heat Pumps2 min read22 July 2026

Should I Repair or Replace My Heat Pump?

Repair or replace your heat pump? An age-based guide, common faults, and the signs a replacement is worthwhile. Honest advice for Whangārei & Kerikeri homes.

If your heat pump isn't performing like it used to, you're probably wondering whether it's worth repairing or if it's time to replace it.

The answer depends on its age, the fault, and how much the repair will cost compared with the value of a newer, more efficient unit.

Heat Pump Age Guide

Less than 5 years old

Most problems are worth repairing.

Units under warranty may have parts covered, and repairs are usually the most economical option.

5–10 years old

This is the grey area.

A simple repair such as replacing a fan motor, sensor or PCB may still represent good value.

10–15 years old

It depends on the fault.

If expensive components such as compressors or refrigerant systems require major work, replacing the unit often makes better financial sense.

Over 15 years old

Modern heat pumps are generally quieter, more efficient and offer improved features such as Wi-Fi control and better air filtration.

If your existing unit requires significant repairs, replacement is often the better long-term investment.

Common Faults

Dirty indoor coil

A professional clean can often restore airflow and efficiency.

Refrigerant leak

Leaks can sometimes be repaired, but the cost depends on where the leak is located.

Faulty PCB

Electronic control boards can often be replaced if parts remain available.

Compressor failure

One of the more expensive repairs.

Depending on the age of the unit, replacement may be the better option.

Signs Replacement May Be Worthwhile

  • Increasing repair frequency
  • Higher power bills
  • Poor heating performance
  • Excessive noise
  • Parts becoming unavailable
  • Rust or corrosion

Benefits of Replacing

Newer models often provide:

  • Lower running costs
  • Better heating performance
  • Quieter operation
  • Improved air filtration
  • Smart phone control
  • Longer warranty

We Can Help You Decide

Our goal isn't simply to sell a new heat pump.

If your existing system can be repaired economically, we'll tell you.

If replacement offers better long-term value, we'll explain the options and provide a clear quotation before any work begins.

Need help with this?

Our team is ready to help. Get in touch for expert advice or a free quote.